US Ambassador Slams Karzai’s ‘Hurtful and Inappropriate’ Remarks

You could say Afghan President Hamid Karzai had it coming. For a while now, the beleaguered Afghan leader has been blasting the US in particular and the US-led coalition in general, often in rambling, bellicose speeches in his native Pashto or Dari.

But even by Karzai’s standards, his address to the Afghanistan Youth International Conference on Saturday hit an all-time US-bashing high.

“You remember a few years ago I was saying thank you to the foreigners for their help, every minute we were thanking them. Now I have stopped saying that,” said Karzai, before going on to add, “They’re here for their own purposes, for their own goals, and they’re using our soil for that.”

Apparently that was too much for outgoing US Ambassador to Afghanistan Karl Eikenberry.

At the end of an address at Herat University Sunday, Eikenberry went on to “add a few words” to his prepared text.

They turned out to be more than just a few words and as the gathering of around 200 students and faculty members gravely listened, the US ambassador launched an unusually emotional response to the international coalition-bashing by “some Afghan leaders”.

Of course he didn’t name the Afghan president, but there was no mistaking who Eikenberry was referring to.

The US ambassador kicked off his personal remarks by noting that along with his wife, he would soon be leaving Afghanistan as his tenure in Kabul comes to an end.

“As we prepare to return home to my family after my most recent two years here – I must tell you that I find occasional comments from some of your leaders hurtful and inappropriate,” he said.

“When Americans, who are serving in your country at great cost – in terms of lives and treasure – hear themselves compared with occupiers, told that they are only here to advance their own interest, and likened to the brutal enemies of the Afghan people … they are filled with confusion and grow weary of our effort here,” he said.

“Mothers and fathers of fallen soldiers, spouses of soldiers who have lost arms and legs, children of those who lost their lives in your country – they ask themselves about the meaning of their loved one’s sacrifice. When I hear some of your leaders call us occupiers, I cannot look at these mourning parents, spouses, and children in the eye,” he said.

Diplomats rarely get emotional – at least not in public and certainly not on the job. But I guess even diplomats can say it as it is at the end of a Kabul posting.

But enough said. I give you Eikenberry in his own words. This speech was broadcast on the private Afghan Tolo TV station. On his Facebook post, the Tolo TV boss Saad Mohseni wrote, “Moving speech by Karl Eikenberry...”

I second that emotion.



Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of FRANCE 24. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. FRANCE 24 is not liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.
The ambassador should take his handbag and hit Karzai with it and also pull Karzai's hair and pinch his leg. What a ridiculous comment Karl, you silly American fool. You've been caught out and are clearly embarrassed. This is a needless war and you Americans think you have a licence to do whatever you want whether in Pakistan, Iraq, Afghanistan or wherever. You really are a fool, in fact a Fool, with a capital "F". Fool
US/NATO coalition is now dropping bombs on Tripoli and Bengazi, as they did with Bagdhad and Kabul. US has dropped bombs in Afghanistan, Iraq, now Libya, Pakistan. people continually complain how wedding parties, factories, schools, hospitals, unarmed men women and children fill the mass graves. Innocents die ten times more than combatants do, Karzai is correct. US/NATO is there for their own private interests, and the people of Afghanistan, Iraq, Pakistan, and the rest of the world can just go to hell. It's time for a Human Revolution towards Sustainability, a clean world for us and our children. "World leaders" need to be treated as the criminals they are, removed from power, maybe they could be useful as janitors. Thank you.
Deeply grateful for your honesty , Your Excellency , Dear Mr.Ambassador Karl Eikenberry , let me express, that it took to long , to hear that at least once - in the last 9 years and 10 months , since 9/11 - from Washington D.C. With my very best regards to you and your loved ones, Christof J. Schmitz
What a hypocrite! Of course we are there for our own commercial interests. Not six months ago it was announced that the mountains of Afghanistan held vast stores of untapped mineral wealth. No country, the U.S. included, ever does anything altruistically. However we are the only country to hypocritically proclaim otherwise. Karzai, unlike Eikenberry, speaks honestly.
Thank you Ambassador Eikenberry, for this heartfelt and truthful statement. The truth is that what American and NATO forces did not realize, in part, I think, and what has become increasingly clear, is that to some extent the corrupt and primitive world of Afghanistan exists already because both the downtrodden and the oppressors native to Afghanistan have not hitherto taken responsibilty for the state of their own country. We have given it a good try, as a powerful, and benevolent civilization must always attempt at first go, but since they seem to respond with arrogance and denial, perhaps the second round should allow for a self-interested, detached enlightened view, and ignore the suffering of those too ignorant to understand where real help lies.

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.